181 responses

  1. zipjet
    October 9, 2011

    I made this yesterday. It was very good warm. It is even better today toasted. It also makes very good sandwiches. Those who complained about the soft crust clearly were not looking for a soft French. This is a great soft French loaf.

    • JoshLovesIt
      October 9, 2011

      I’m glad you enjoyed it! Hopefully it’ll become a family favorite, like in our home!

      • Mellody
        December 9, 2012

        I”ve already made 4 loaves and can’t get enough…so good…thanks for sharing!!!!

      • JoshLovesIt
        March 9, 2013

        Mellody, thanks for your comment, and I’m happy that the bread turned out so great for you!

      • Emily
        June 15, 2014

        Can I hv the measures in g/ml plz? I’m new to cooking and a bit difficult for me to follow the ingredient in cups…thx much an I love ur website and channel

      • JoshLovesIt
        June 20, 2014

        Hi Emily, you can find all sorts of online measurement conversions. But when I’ve got time I’ll try to give the metric measurements too. Thanks for watching!

      • Sierra
        December 19, 2014

        Your recipe is really very good, since I’ve been searching for good soft French bread recipes for a long time until I’ve tried yours today. It is very simple and turns out very good. Thank you so much!
        Just one small question, you mentioned the bake time is 20 minutes, however, I spent nearly about 35 minutes to turn it into a little golden, and I dont know why there would be such a great difference. Whatever, it tastes so good! Both me and my husband love it!

      • JoshLovesIt
        December 31, 2014

        Sierra, I’m glad you enjoyed the bread! Everyone’s oven is different. Perhaps your temperature is off? You can purchase a thermometer that can sit inside your oven to test the temperature. But if if turned out fine, then just adjust the recipe for your oven!

    • kim
      November 10, 2013

      I wanted to know how many slices per loaf you get, roughly?

      • JoshLovesIt
        November 14, 2013

        Hi Kim, thanks for your question. This is a tough question, because it depends on how big your slices are!

  2. Denise
    December 29, 2011

    Thanks so much for making a easy and clear to understand video the bread came out so good we took a pic and i posted it on my facebook page thanks again:)

    • JoshLovesIt
      December 29, 2011

      Fantastic Denise! I’m glad that you enjoyed it. How did you find JoshLovesIt.com?

      • Denise
        December 29, 2011

        Hi Josh

        I went to you tube first and punched in french bread how to make and i watched one other video just before yours his video looked easy too but when he sliced and took a bite when the bread was done it sounded way too crunchy probably the 35 min cook time he asked for what i did use from his video was i used a ceramic bowl i washed it with hot water first then dried it out so the bowl was warm before adding the ingredients and on the 1st rise i used a emty plastic grocery bag tied a knot so it was tight around the bowl. if you want to see the picture go to facebook under Denise Bodge you’ll see i was so proud breadbefore never ever worked out so bad we had went out and bought a fancy bread machine even that is not as good as your recipe!

      • JoshLovesIt
        December 29, 2011

        Great Denise! I can’t seem to find you on Facebook, so if you could please “like” JoshLovesIt.com on Facebook, I can see your bread. Thanks!

      • Denise
        December 30, 2011

        i posted the pic on your facebook chk it out :)

  3. Linda D
    January 8, 2012

    Wow – awesome easy recipe made 2x now and today a double batch with my grandaughter 9yrs old she said so easy and took one home for mom and dad thx Josh for sharing. God Bless you

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 8, 2012

      Thanks Linda! I’m glad this was helpful, and I hope it becomes a tradition in your family as it has in ours! How did you find JoshLovesIt.com?

  4. mary
    January 9, 2012

    I just started making homemade bread because I found this recipe via your video and it looked so easy and tasty. Now, maybe it’s because I’m a newbie at bread making, but I printed your instructions and unfortunately it wasn’t detailed enough for me to remember from your video that I was supposed to knead the dough before letting it rise the first time. Then I didnt remember to let it rise again after I had shaped it on the sheet;. Not remembering the first part wasn’t a big deal because not too much time passed before I realized I was supposed to knead it before letting it rise, but it may have made a slight difference when I had put the bread in the oven before letting it rise again. It was in the oven 5 minutes before I realized my mistake. I took it out and tried to see if it would rise. It looked like it rose a little. Then I baked it 20 minutes as instructed. The other problem I encountered was I had a packet of the yeast, not a container of it. So when I measured it out, it was a little less than a tablespoon. I dont know if missing that little bit makes a difference or not. I tried to adjust the rest of the recipe. In any case, regardless of the mistakes, the bread still came out pretty good. I would say a bit denser than it looked when you made it because I didn’t let it rise properly. I will have to try this again following your exact instructions.

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 10, 2012

      Thanks for enjoying my bread! I’ll clarify the recipe when I get some time. Thanks for the feedback, and please have your friends subscribe here at JoshLovesIt.com!

  5. Evelyn A.
    January 10, 2012

    Was wondering if you wanted to make the french bread with wheat flour what would the recipe changes be?
    I am trying to not use white flour as often and would love to try making this recipe later in the week.
    Can’t wait to try it out!
    Liked watching your video on YOUTube.
    You make making bread look real easy.
    Thanks,
    Evelyn A.

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 12, 2012

      Hi Evelyn,

      I completely understand your desire to make this recipe a bit healthier. It doesn’t work well with all whole wheat, but try substituting half of the white flour with whole wheat flour. Please let me know what you think! But at the end of the day, I eat whole wheat bread 6 days per week and eat this 1 day per week. I’m still way ahead in terms of health!

      Josh

      • JoshLovesIt
        January 13, 2012

        One more thing. My brother-in-law Vince makes this almost every weekend, so this is what he says to tell you:

        “Use up to fifty percent whole wheat flour, and let it raise longer. More than half whole wheat makes it too heavy. You can also add rolled oats or rolled wheat instead of some of the flour. Just don’t let the dough get too stiff or heavy.”

        Does this help?

        Josh

      • kim
        November 10, 2013

        I did his one and it definitely took longer to bake. was still very good, denser but good

      • JoshLovesIt
        November 14, 2013

        Hi Kim, yes baking times definitely can vary due to elevation, humidity, etc. Try toasting the bread…you’ll love it toasted with butter!

  6. Nadir
    January 12, 2012

    It is definitely one the world’s BEST french bread I’ve ever tried. I saw the video and for what it looked like I decided to try it, you can guess the texture for how it looks. So, I immediately went to the kitchen and cooked this heavenly delicious bread for dinner. My wife and I adored it. We will cook this bread from now on. It is true, believe me, we are NOT buying brands anymore. We will cook Josh’s french bread. If you don’t let the dough to rise too much and put it inside a Pullman Loaf Pan, you can cook it in shape of delicious English bread and make sandwiches. I’ve got many ideas for this recipe. I really thank Josh for sharing this, I’ve been looking for a recipe like this for centuries. Cheers!

  7. Joy
    January 22, 2012

    This recipe is excellent and good not only for french bread but for hamburger buns and hotdog buns as well… i have a recipe i use for crusty french baguettes and for torpedo loaves like for french dip sandwiches but for all other bread needs this has turned out far superior and adaptive… oregano and sun-dried tomato and even olive work well with this bread as well as some of the hard cheese like Parmesan. Thanks again Josh for sharing.

    Joy from NC
    Baker of all breads

  8. Marisol
    January 22, 2012

    Josh very good, I just made some and they turned out so good and soft..this was my second time making french bread and I nailed it thanks to your family recipe!

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 22, 2012

      Marisol, thank you so much for trying out my bread, and I’m so glad it worked out for you. We made it for some friends tonight, and it was a hit. Please send your friends to subscribe on my blog!!

  9. Wendy
    January 22, 2012

    Josh,

    I made both your soft french bread and your cinnamon rolls today. I really enjoyed both. I plan on using some of the leftover bread for making sandwiches tomorrow. I will definitely make both again. By the way, I made the dough for both in my bread machines. I made the French bread dough in my zojirushi which has two paddles, and it did a great job. My zo has a fast dough cycle which takes about 36 minutes. I let it sit and rest for about 30 minutes in the bread machine after the cycle completed, and then rolled it out as you described. I then let it rise in a slightly warm oven for about an hour before baking it. I did cut back on the water slightly as I frequently have to do for most recipes and still had to add a bit more flour.

    I have made some pretty good cinnamon rolls before, but I think that the cream cheese icing is an improvement over the confectioner sugar icing that I have been using.

    I was searching for bread blogs and bread recipes when I ran across your site.

    Wendy

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 22, 2012

      Wendy, you’re amazing! I’m so glad that you experimented and gave feedback. Have you subscribed yet?

      • Wendy
        January 22, 2012

        I subscribed a little earlier tonight but I haven’t yet received the verification email, but I will be on the lookout for it.

        Wendy

  10. Gary
    January 30, 2012

    Looking for primarily a good sandwich bread like for cold cuts, cheeses, etc. Does this bread fill that need?
    Is this bread good only the day it is baked or will it keep a couple of days at a good quality level?
    Thank you

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 30, 2012

      Hi Gary,

      Yes, this is amazing for sandwiches, especially if you want to turn one loaf into a large submarine sandwich for multiple people. This bread is good for multiple days. We actually freeze what we don’t eat the first day, and at still tastes great later. Try slicing the bread before you freeze it, and then toast however many slices you prefer. It is the best toasting bread, especially with butter! Let me know what you think!

  11. Wendy
    February 1, 2012

    Josh,

    I think that I am addicted to this bread now. I have made it three times in 3 weeks. Of course, we having been eating the bread when I first make it and then sandwiches the next day or two. I even used some for making bread crumbs for Parmesan chicken. I just chopped it pretty fine in a food processor and then toasted the bread crumbs. Thanks for sharing a great recipe.

    I am still making the dough in my bread machine, so 2 cups of water and @ 5 1/2 cups of flour is what is working best for me.

    Wendy

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 1, 2012

      Wendy, I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed this family recipe!

  12. Tom
    February 13, 2012

    Excellent video Josh. I’m headed to the kitchen after hitting the send button… All the while listening I kept saying I wish I had free time- I’d remove you floor noise from the video so you’d not have the ever-present background hiss.
    Down load “Audacity” (free program) follow 3 steps and you could remove it yourself. Just isolate the noise floor and then let the program do it for you after you define what the noise is. Many YouTube videos can show you the simple 3 steps. You’ll be elated. Then you’ll have just your voice. It will be easier to listen to. But hey, right now, we’re talking bread. And in this realm- you are king!
    Thanks for your video.

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 13, 2012

      Hey Tom,

      Thanks for the advice! I’ve got Audacity, so I’ll have to figure that out. Let me know how the bread turns out!

      • darlene
        March 30, 2014

        #33. On your website French bread where the guy Tom told you about audacity, he was telling you you needed Audacity to clear the background noises in you video . Not that you had audacity. Wee any way I will had a little and can’t wait to try your bread as well as your cinnamon rolls.

  13. Val
    February 15, 2012

    I absolutely LOVE this bread! I made some and shared it with my next door neighbor and for her next party she had me make 8 loaves… 8! Everyone adored it and begged for the recipe… soooo I steered them all to your web site. It has never failed me and I have probably made it 30 times in the last 4 months. Thank you so much for sharing.

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 15, 2012

      Excellent Val! Thanks for your comment. And thanks for sharing my blog with others…that’s very appreciated. If you could please get others to subscribe on my homepage, and “like” my facebook box, that would also be awesome!

  14. MCUARON
    February 23, 2012

    I made this recipe yesterday and it tastes delicious! My mother and father in law, husband and even my picky brother in law loved it! since i love spicy foods i added jalapenos to some of the bread before baking and it still tasted delicious. i will definitely be keeping this recipe. thank you!

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 24, 2012

      Excellent! I have also tried jalapenos, but added mozzarella cheese too! Just spread the peppers and cheese out on the rolled out rectangle, and then roll it up. It is sooo good!

  15. Zedz
    March 2, 2012

    I made this a few days ago and already the family is asking me to make more! Thanks for posting it!

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 2, 2012

      Hi Zedz, I’m glad you like the recipe for the bread! How did you find it?

  16. Pamlea Logan
    April 18, 2012

    Hi Josh,

    Do you have any ideas of how to adjust this recipe for convection ovens? I haven’t made it yet, I just came across you while looking for bread recipes on Youtube.

    • JoshLovesIt
      April 18, 2012

      Whoa, great question Pamela! I don’t have a convection oven, but I suspect the baking time would be reduced. I’d pull it out around 15 minutes & cut it open to see if there is any doughiness. Will you please let me know what you find? I’d like to include that in my video and article. Thanks!

  17. Amber
    April 19, 2012

    Hi Josh, My husband is French and we live in France, so I am excited about trying this recipe.
    When I make it, we’ll see how it stands up beside the bread we buy at the bakery in Paris! :)
    Before I start, I would like to know if it is possible to let the dough rise for more than 2 hours and finish it later. For example, can I let it rise overnight and finish it in the morning? I don’t know about everyone else, but I don’t always have exactly 2 hours to go away and come back. And I would ask the same question for the 2 hours on the baking sheet, can it be longer?
    Also, I wanted to ask about freezing the dough. Ideally, this is a recipe for fresh bread, but can the dough be frozen and pulled out on a rainy day? If so, at what point would you advise freezing it?
    Lastly, I would like to know if it this recipe can be done with whole wheat flour. I’m just curious.
    Thanks for sharing!
    -Amber

    • JoshLovesIt
      April 19, 2012

      Hi Amber,

      Thanks for your questions! Wow, I love Paris! And yes, bread in Paris is amazing. Yikes, I’m not sure how this bread will sand up next to genuine French Bread…it’s more of an American take on French bread, but it sure is popular. I’ll try to answer your questions:

      1. “…can I let it rise overnight and finish it in the morning?”

      I have never let bread dough rise overnight, but I have done it with Pizza dough. With pizza dough, I stop the rising process by placing it in the fridge. The rising can then resume once out of the fridge. Just experiment, and be sure to let me know what you discover, as I’d love to update my article.

      2. “…can the dough be frozen and pulled out on a rainy day?”

      Another great question. Although this bread freezes incredibly well after it’s baked, I haven’t tried freezing the dough. I do know that you can freeze dough (you need to change the yeast quantity and type), but for this particular bread recipe I haven’t tried it (but you got me curious, so I will now). Below I’m sharing a link for a good tutorial on freezing dough. Please let me know how it turns out!

      http://breadbaking.about.com/od/beginnerbasics/ht/freezedough.htm

      P.S. I’ve got a great pizza recipe coming, so be sure to subscribe!

      • Amber
        April 28, 2012

        Hey Josh, Thanks for your reply. My mother and brothers in the U.S. are now making your bread also! I still haven’t tried it, but they will tell me how it comes out. We were wondering when you freeze it after baking it, how do you do it? Plastic wrap and foil? Looking forward to your reply. Best, Amber

      • JoshLovesIt
        April 29, 2012

        Hi Amber, you can either put the whole loaf in plastic wrap or a large storage container, or cut it in slices then put it in a freezer bag. That way you can toast 1 piece at a time! Make sure you put some soft real butter on the toast!

  18. Europe
    June 4, 2012

    Hi, this recipe contains too much sugar for a french bread. French breads are not so sweet, just their desserts are:)

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 18, 2013

      Thanks for your comment! Certainly this is not a traditional French bread…just a spin off, but it certainly is tasty, and very popular with a lot of people. (P.S. Sorry for the late reply to your comment..for some reason, these comments haven’t been emailed to me lately).

  19. Justin
    September 5, 2012

    Hi Josh, I am from India and I’ve always (badly) wanted to be able to bake my own bread. I have traveled a bit (both US and Europe) and after tasting the breads there, have never liked the bread I pick from the stores here in India – they just don’t taste the way they do in Europe. The last few days, I have been browsing and watching videos in youtube to find a very simple yet good recipe to bake – I’ve never baked bread before! Last night, I saw your video and today, I decided I would try it out. My biggest worry was, I have a microwave oven that can be used as convection too, and it has maximum temperature setting upto 250 C only – I still went ahead and tried!

    UNBELIEVABLE is the word. I never thought it would come out exactly the way I saw in your video. I am still wearing a big smile (4 hours after) out of excitement as I type this. This bread is right among the top ones I’ve tasted.

    While I kept one loaf the way you made, the second one, while rolling, I sprinkled bits of garlic, rosemary and oregano and I just loved both the loaves!!

    Thank you (& your mom) so much for sharing this recipe.

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 20, 2013

      Justin, thanks for trying out my bread recipe! I’m so happy that it worked so well for you also. (P.S. Sorry about my detailed response..for some reason, my comments aren’t being delivered to my email inbox).

  20. ness
    September 21, 2012

    my daughter is a bread lover so I came across this site and recipe, on youtube, will make today, and sure enough it will be gone today! thanks for the recipe!

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 20, 2013

      Ness, thanks for your comment..did the bread turn out as well as you hoped? (P.S. Sorry about my detailed response..for some reason, my comments aren’t being delivered to my email inbox).

  21. Kat
    October 4, 2012

    I have been looking for a soft french bread recipe and I stumbled across this one after searching forever. It is rising nicely at the moment I can’t wait to see how it turns out :-D

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 20, 2013

      Kat, thanks for your comment. How did the bread turn out? (P.S. Sorry about my extremely detailed response..for some reason, my comments aren’t being delivered to my email inbox).

  22. Kerryn
    October 8, 2012

    Hi Josh
    i made the bread today and had a problem with it rising, it formed a hard skin on top and took a really long time to rise. Don’t know what i did wrong or what you could suggest??
    Thanks
    Kerryn

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 20, 2013

      Kerryn, thanks for your question. Sorry about my extremely detailed response..for some reason, my comments aren’t being delivered to my email inbox. As for your rising problem, it could be a result of several things. Did you use the yeast that I recommended? Did you cover the dough? Did you place the dough in a warm area?

  23. Jolene
    October 20, 2012

    Thank you for sharing. Terrific recipe and thanks to the others for their contributions as well!

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      You’re welcome Jolene! Sorry for my delay in responding!

  24. Abe
    October 21, 2012

    This is great! Just wondering, what is the difference between your mom’s recipe and a regular crusty french bread recipe? Thanks!

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Hi Abe, thanks for your question…sorry for the delayed response. My mother’s recipe is not a traditional french bread recipe, but a modified version. It’s more light, soft, and fluffy, whereas traditional french bread has a hard crust and a soft center.

  25. Debra
    November 23, 2012

    Hi Josh, just viewed your video on the French bread and it looks amazing. I’ll definitely make it sometime this weekend. However, I do have a question for you…I have Active yeast, not the quick acting , how much do I use of the Active? I made bread yesterday for Thanksgiving for the 1st time using an Artisan recipe I found on Youtube and it came out great. But I would love to make your’s too. Thank you for your recipe and answer to my question.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Hi Debra, sorry for the delay in answering your question..I’m having some problems with the commenting service. Active yeast will just take longer, but you can probably use the same amount…just watch the size of the bread.

  26. Sukaina
    November 27, 2012

    Hi Josh
    I am very anxious to try out your recipe for the french bread.
    It looks amazingly “do able!”
    Question: Can I substitute the white flour with brown?

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Hi Sukaina, sorry for the delay. Yes, you can use whole wheat flour, but only up to half. All whole wheat tastes too “grainy”. Does that help?

  27. Mellody
    November 28, 2012

    I am going to try and make this tomorrow….wish me luck! You did a great job on the video!!!

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Thanks Mellody! How did your bread turn out?

  28. Geri
    December 12, 2012

    First time to view your wonderful French bread recipe. Going to try it this weekend. I have a question about “yeast” I have a jar of “active dry yeast’ how does rapid rise differ from active dry? Thank you!

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Hi Geri, great question. Active dry yeast is normal yeast, and rapid yeast speeds up the fermentation process, and makes your wait time shorter. Does that answer your question?

      • Geri
        March 9, 2013

        Hi Josh, Have you reset your clock for spring? Must rise and shine Sunday and get the bread in the oven on time. :) Thanks so much for your reply. Now I’m ready to bake.

    • Comeau
      March 15, 2014

      Since I have regular yeast on board-all I do is proof it first in a 2 cup pyrex measuring cup. . Put the yeast-water and sugar in/stir till dissolved, till it gets nice and bubbly-then continue on with the recipe as normal. It came out perfecto!

      • JoshLovesIt
        March 18, 2014

        I’m glad the bread worked out for you!

  29. Jake
    December 17, 2012

    You should knead the dough more. Let it rise longer. Cook it hotter. Also pay attention to the humidity of the dough, which usually requires you make measurements by weight. 60%-80%. Higher water content would result in a better texture for french bread. However, your kneading technique will have to change at the higher humidities.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Thanks for your suggestions Jake!

  30. Amber
    January 3, 2013

    This bread was good. The family loved it. I put vegan butter on top when it was done. I also turned some of it into garlic bread. I will definitely make this again.

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 18, 2013

      I’m glad you liked it Amber! I’ll have to try the vegan butter…which brand is best? And thanks for your comment! (P.S. Sorry for the late reply to your comment..for some reason, these comments haven’t been emailed to me lately).

  31. Bass Player
    January 28, 2013

    Man ! I tried this for my very first attempt at any bread making and it came out fabulous! Just delicious. I love cooking New Orleans food and I wanted to learn how to make my own French Bread to serve on the side. This recipe Killed It !! Gonna serve it to my friends Super Bowl Sunday with some Shrimp Jambalaya ……Thanks Josh !

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 18, 2013

      You’re welcome…I’m glad you liked it! (P.S. Sorry for the late reply to your comment..for some reason, these comments haven’t been emailed to me lately).

      • Amber
        February 18, 2013

        Hi Josh. My favorite is Earth Balance-Organic Buttery Spread (Whipped). I have also tried the original and that is fine too. I use the tub, but Earth Balance also has Vegan Buttery Sticks, which I am sure would make it a litte easier to butter the loaves. Thank you for sharing this recipe. Can’t wait to make it again. Next time I want to mix whole wheat pastry flour and unbleached white flour. I am not sure how that will change the amount of flour I have to use though.

      • JoshLovesIt
        March 9, 2013

        I’ll have to try that Amber!

  32. Dale
    February 18, 2013

    Josh, can I use raw sugar instead of regular sugar? Also does it make a difference if I use Sea salt or Kosher Salt? I can’t wait to make this it looks wonderful.

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 18, 2013

      Hi Dale,

      I actually haven’t tested this recipe with raw sugar or Sea Salt. Perhaps you can experiment, and come back and update this comment with your results?

    • Amber
      February 18, 2013

      Hi Dale:

      I used sea salt and I used raw sugar when I made this bread and it came out just fine.

  33. Lisa
    February 19, 2013

    I loved this bread recipe! I am excited to make your other ones! Thank you so much for sharing this, I am not a good cook at all. But I can make the best bread now! Thank you again.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Lisa, thanks for your comment, and I’m glad that you liked the bread!

  34. Feby
    March 3, 2013

    Hi Josh,

    I tried your recipe today. It was delicious! Very soft and every body at my house loved it.

    I adjusted the recipe a little bit. I live in Indonesia and this is rainy season…., so I knew 2.5 cups of water was too much. I’ve tried a pizza crust recipe last month with the water measurement as written in the recipe…..I learned my lesson :D
    I used only 2 cups and it was enough for the full 6 cups of flour.

    I did used only 1/3 cups of sugar, because I didn’t want it to sweet for dinner rolls. But I guess for breakfast or afternoon tea, the full 1/2 cup would be perfect.

    Thank you for the recipe.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 9, 2013

      Hi Feby! I’m happy to hear that someone from Indonesia is reading my website!

  35. Fiona
    March 14, 2013

    Hi there Josh,

    Well this was fantastic bread, My bread machine died over the weekend (overworked) and so I searched the web and found this recipe, I made it in my Kenwood (it will do all the work)

    I made 2 yesterday and took 1 loaf over to our son and his family as we were going there for Dinner, we made half the loaf into garlic parsley and cheese bread to eat with out Dinner yum it was very delish, our Grandson is lactos intollerant so this bread was perfect for him to eat with his special butter and cheese, thank you so much I am making another as I am writing this.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 14, 2013

      Hi Fiona, I’m glad that you liked the bread! Where are you writing from?

      • Fiona
        March 14, 2013

        I live in Auckland New Zealand.

      • JoshLovesIt
        March 15, 2013

        Great! I’m glad that my website has traveled to Kiwi Land!

  36. Valerie
    March 20, 2013

    Thank you Rene! I was looking for this for years… God bless you.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 21, 2013

      Valerie, I’m glad that you found what you’re looking for! I’ll tell my mother that you were grateful for this recipe.

  37. AMF
    March 24, 2013

    Hi there,
    Ran out of bread (we get it for free usually) and thought I’d try making some myself this time and happened across your vid on youtube. You made it look so simple I tried it pretty much right away. Came out brilliantly, kids were thrilled, I couldn’t stop eating it. Will be making more. Maybe rolled up with cheese and bacon and maybe some with cinnamon and sultanas. Very grateful to you for sharing and to your mum for teaching you.
    God bless from Australia,
    AMF

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 25, 2013

      Hi AMF from Australia! Thanks for the compliment, and I’m so happy that you enjoyed the bread! I really enjoy putting mozzarella cheese and jalapeno peppers inside before I roll the dough up. We’ve also successfully tried cheese, pizza sauce, and pepperoni.

  38. Becky
    April 9, 2013

    Just one word for this bread…YUMMM
    This was a easy recipe to follow, and taste so good.

    • JoshLovesIt
      May 9, 2013

      Thanks Becky! I’m glad you enjoyed it!

  39. Angelia
    April 25, 2013

    When you make this dish you must have Patience & Time I had just got off work at 5:15 and arrived at home 6:00pm I really wanted to try the recipe so despite the hour I did it. I used my kitchen aid and did not use as much water according to your recipe. I must say I got inpatient and after the 2nd rise I only waited 45 minutes I ended up baking for about 25 minutes. The aroma throughout my home was like, I was living in a BAKERY… the texture, taste of the bread was delicious. Next time I make this FRIDAY (will use my breadman this time) I will be able to let my bread rise according to your post. Oh and by the way my husband said it was the BEST bread I had ever made. WOW! Thanks to you and MOM

    • JoshLovesIt
      May 9, 2013

      Thanks Angelia! Yes, bread can be time consuming, but well worth it!

  40. Edward
    May 3, 2013

    Hi Josh

    In your Youtube video you say to add 1 and 1/2 cup of sugar, but here in the recipe you say add 1/2 cup. So which is correct 1 1/2 cup or only 1/2 cup?

    • JoshLovesIt
      May 9, 2013

      I’m sorry Edward…I didn’t speak very clearly. I said 1/2 Cup of sugar.

  41. Flyn
    May 6, 2013

    Hi Josh,

    Can’t wait to try out your recipe. I have some leftover bread flour. I wonder can I use that to replace all purpose flour?

    Flyn from Singapore

    • JoshLovesIt
      May 9, 2013

      Hi Flyn,

      Thanks for your question! I’m sure you can use bread flour…give it a try, and please let me know how it works!

  42. Cindy
    June 14, 2013

    I’ve made this before and it was amazing. Simple, delicious and worth
    every minute it takes lol. I am making it now again for tonight’s dinner.
    I must say, I can’t wait to wake up the next morning and have some
    of it toasted, drip butter all over it. Love the bread…. thanks again!

    ps, I reduced recipe to make one loaf. (almost out of flour) :0 lol

    • JoshLovesIt
      July 18, 2013

      Hi Cindy, sorry for my delayed response, but thanks for your letting me know how much you enjoy the bread!

  43. Layla
    June 23, 2013

    Thank you Josh for this AMAZING recipee. We already made this twice. Once exactly like yours and the second time I replaced 2,5 cups all purpose flour with multigrain flour. I put in it an extra teaspoon of yeast. It was also very delicious. Thank you one more time Josh. Your recipee became the “recipee of our house”.

    • JoshLovesIt
      July 18, 2013

      Hi Layla, sorry for my delayed response, but thanks for your comment! I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, and also that you innovated and tried a modification!

  44. Cass
    July 2, 2013

    Just made this bread for a dinner party and it was an absolute hit! Thanks for posting it, Josh!

    • JoshLovesIt
      July 18, 2013

      Great Cass!

  45. Suzen
    July 4, 2013

    Ok, I have tried making bread many, many times and never overly successfully. I tried this recipe and followed your instructions, using my KitchenAid mixer for the mixing and kneading. I mixed it and then kneaded for two mins, let rest for seven, knead for two, rest for seven, knead for two. Let it rest for a few mins. Then I let it rise. WOW. I put it in the oven with a pan of warm water for two hrs, like you said, and it was HUGE when it came out. Then on the second rise it was the biggest loaves of bread I’ve ever made. Then came the test; my very picky husband. He LOVED it and so did my kids. It was soft, chewy and delicious. Even the dog loved it. He heard the words “more bread” and came running out for his share. Ty so much for this recipe and the pictures and video were VERY helpful.

    • JoshLovesIt
      July 18, 2013

      Hi Suzen, sorry for my delayed response, but thanks for your comment. I’m so happy that you enjoyed the bread recipe! Feel free to share some of your favorite recipes with me!

  46. Linda
    August 10, 2013

    Josh! I made your french bread! It turned out wonderful!!!
    The only thing I would do different is pass on rubbing it
    with butter. It made the crust too soggy . Otherwise, it
    was awesome and tasted light and flavorful!

    • JoshLovesIt
      August 11, 2013

      Thanks for letting me know Linda, and thanks for your suggestion!

  47. Jerri
    August 16, 2013

    Jerri loves it too A little too sweet for me, but that’s easy to fix. Great wuth dinner, great for toast, and really great sandwich bread. Thanks, Josh! (BTW, I used half AP flour and half bread flour, worked like a charm,)

    • JoshLovesIt
      August 21, 2013

      Fantastic Jerri! I’m glad that you liked it.

  48. Mike
    August 31, 2013

    Thanks for the recipe for French bread is awesome thanks again.

    • JoshLovesIt
      September 10, 2013

      Thanks Mike! How did you find this recipe?

  49. Sue
    November 7, 2013

    You make it look so easy! I am not a cook. I have copied your recipe for French bread and the way you make it seem easy makes me want to give it a try. I have no electric mixer tho.
    Here’s hoping!
    Thank you

    • JoshLovesIt
      November 14, 2013

      Hi Sue, how did it turn out? Don’t worry, my mom didn’t use an electric mixer either :)

  50. Holly
    December 4, 2013

    Bread is my guilty pleasure. My father makes amazing bread but I moved out and have been trying different recipes for a long time. It is a simple and straight forward recipe, and it turned out deliciously. (I admit to not letting it rise long enough because I was so excited for it, though).

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 17, 2014

      Great Holly, I’m glad you liked the bread recipe. Please spread the word about JoshLovesIt.com!

  51. Jill
    December 8, 2013

    I just made this wonderful bread…Yummy. I used the dough setting on my bread maker then rolled it out and let it rise the 2nd time on the cookie sheet. I didn’t think I cooked it enough because it really didn’t brown but when I cut a slice, it was perfect! I have found the perfect French bread recipe!!!! I am wondering how it would cook and taste if I put it in a bread pan after rolling it out… any thoughts??? I think I will try it next time with one of the loaves. Thanks for posting an easy wonderful recipe. I love it.

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 17, 2014

      I’m glad you liked it Jill! Yes, we’ve also baked this in a bread loaf pan, and it turns out great. Please spread the word about JoshLovesIt.com!

  52. Melinda
    December 19, 2013

    Josh, I’m a newbie at making bread also. I cannot wait to try this recipe! Looks yummy. Can this recipe be used for dinner rolls or do you have a dinner roll recipe? I did not see one in your bread recipe list.
    Happy baking, Melinda.

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 17, 2014

      Hi Linda, sorry for the slow response. I’ve never tried this recipe as dinner rolls, but I don’t see why it wouldn’t work! Will you please try it and let me know how it turns out? I could update the article to let others know.

      • Melinda
        February 3, 2014

        I finally tried this recipe for dinner rolls. It turned out great! It makes a ton, lol. Thanks for sharing this recipe! I make it once or twice a week, so easy and delish!

      • JoshLovesIt
        February 7, 2014

        Wow Melinda, that’s great! Any advice on how you did the rolls?

      • Melinda
        February 10, 2014

        Hey Josh, I didn’t do anything specific. I just divided the dough in half. I made 2 small loaves with half and about 24 balls with the other half. I let them rise, then baked them. It only took about 8-10 minutes to bake the rolls. So yummy! :)

  53. Heidi
    January 8, 2014

    This is the best bread that I have ever had !! My family can’t stop raving about it!! I can’t thank you enough, Josh!!

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 17, 2014

      I’m so happy to hear that Heidi! I hope you share my blog with others!

  54. Hiomara l
    January 15, 2014

    Can I use bread flour?

    • JoshLovesIt
      January 17, 2014

      I haven’t tried bread flour, but you could give it a try. Bread flour has higher gluten, so it may affect the size of the loaf. Let me know what you find out!

  55. malthida1234
    January 19, 2014

    i like this so i want to try today

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 7, 2014

      Hi Mathilda! How did my french bread recipe work out for you?

  56. Chelz
    February 5, 2014

    Going to try this out. My husband and I used to live in New Orleans and buy the most amazing soft French bread at the stores there. You can’t get anything like it in the rest of the country. You can order the wonderful Reising loaf online but with shipping factored in its almost $20 per loaf! Hoping this recipe will fill the void! We’ll let ya know!

    • JoshLovesIt
      February 7, 2014

      Great Chelz! Did it turn out all right?

  57. Daniel Flores
    February 15, 2014

    I have made this twice. I have added a small twist though. When I roll the dough out I spread 1/2 tablespoon olive oil and then sprinkle with Dean Jacobs’ Rosemary and Garlic bread dipping seasoning. My Kids love it.

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 18, 2014

      Daniel, sorry for my late reply. I’m glad to hear about your variation on my bread recipe!

  58. Ann N
    February 27, 2014

    I just found your recipe this morning and was able to bake the bread before my kids came home from school. They love eating the hot French bread with homemade hot chocolate for their snack! I had to use a stand mixer because my arms have no strength to mix and knead the dough by hand. I was afraid it wasn’t going to turn out well, but it did! I’m so happy!

    Thank you for this easy recipe!

    Ann

    • JoshLovesIt
      March 18, 2014

      Ann, I’m so glad that the bread turned out great for you. Thanks for visiting JoshLovesIt.com!

  59. Comeau
    March 15, 2014

    I just made this for the 2nd time. Wow! The best! This is a keeper for sure! Your mom must be a fantastic cook! and you were lucky to learn from her. thanks so much for sharing a wonderful recipe!

  60. Fran
    April 10, 2014

    Thanks for the great recipe, i loved it!

  61. Fran
    April 10, 2014

    hi

  62. Fran
    April 10, 2014

    Hello?

  63. Fran
    April 10, 2014

    Excuse me?

  64. Sam
    May 1, 2014

    I have made this three times in the past four days. It keeps disappearing to the neighbors houses. Truly great. I brush on egg white prior to baking, it tends to crisp the crust just a bit a gives it a more golden brown look. Great simple way to make wonderful bread.

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Good job Sam! Thanks for letting me know.

  65. Christie
    May 3, 2014

    Josh, I need your help!!!! I am trying to get the ingredients list from your Rene’s French Bread, but there is an overlay over the ingredients. I am also unable, because of a messed up Prental Block Mode, from clicking on the “Print Recipe” Icon. WHERE ELSE might I find this recipe so that I can write it down and TRY IT??????
    Thanks! Christie from California

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Hi Christie, have you tried a different web browser? Some browsers (like Internet Explorer) mess things up. It works fine on google chrome.

  66. Inga
    May 11, 2014

    I’m trying this for the first time today, and in oder to get the consistency like in your video, I had to add much more flour than 6 1/2 cups. Fingers crossed it still turns out well :)

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Did it work out? Maybe you have thicker water in your part of the world? JK :)

  67. Momstheword11
    June 1, 2014

    I cannot get bread to rise. I don’t know why. I follow directions. Each time I think maybe this time it will work but no, sadly. Is yeast sometimes allergic to some people or something? WHYrs ME? WHY ANYONE? Such a terrible curse to be “yeast challenged”!!

    Any thoughts would be appreciated, thanks. Great video!

  68. Momstheword11
    June 1, 2014

    I cannot get bread to rise. I don’t know why. I follow directions. Each time I think maybe this time it will work but no, sadly. Is yeast sometimes allergic to some people or something? WHY ME? WHY ANYONE? Such a terrible curse to be “yeast challenged”!!

    Any thoughts would be appreciated, thanks. Great video!

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Hi there, are you placing the bread in a warm area with a dark cloth to rise? Also, your yeast could be old. Make sure you try the yeast that I recommended. Did any of this help?

  69. Gaby
    June 3, 2014

    Hi Josh, I would like to know if I can use instant Yeast intead of rapid yeast?
    thanks for sharing this wonderful recipe.

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Hi Gaby, I’m not too sure of the difference, but it couldn’t hurt too much to try, right?

      • Gaby
        June 20, 2014

        Thanks so much Josh, I love this recipe, it’s awesome! I did tried the instant yeast and it works just fine, not much difference I also added some brown sugar and cinnamon to make “pan dulce” ( sweet bread) delicious!!

  70. Momstheword11
    June 6, 2014

    Dear Josh,
    I just made this and it worked. It is the first bread I ever made that we can actually eat. BTW, I noticed while making this that it is essentially the same as a pretzel dough recipe I have been wanting to try, so I divided the dough in half and that worked also! We love this recipe and it is so easy!!
    Thanks:)

    • JoshLovesIt
      June 20, 2014

      Yay! Now I know how to make pretzels, thanks to you!!!

      • Jean Adhya
        June 20, 2014

        XD

  71. Daniel
    July 11, 2014

    I have made this recipe several times. It is a favorite with my kids. I have added a small twist to it though.

    after I spread the dough and before i roll it, i brush the dough with olive oil and Dean Jacob’s Rosa Maria spices to it. (Garlic Salt, Rosemary, parsley, thyme , oregano, black pepper). The bread does not make it thru the weekend.

    Experiment with this.

    DFLores

    • JoshLovesIt
      August 20, 2014

      Thanks for letting me know how you customized it!

  72. Sheila
    July 15, 2014

    Hi Josh, happened upon your video after watching one on sweet milk buns. I was so happy to find yours.
    it does not require a fancy bread machine, but only a wooden spoon, and uses all purpose flour. Can’t wait to make it.
    I love the older recipes, one I make often is a scone recipe I got from an aunt years ago.
    Sheila

    • JoshLovesIt
      August 20, 2014

      I hope it turned out great for you!

  73. Terry
    July 25, 2014

    Thank you, Josh. Your mother’s recipe is wonderful. I’m not strong enough to use my hands, so I let my mixer do the work. I pull out the dough hook, cover and let It do it’s first rise under the mixer. The rest is per your instructions. The first two bakings were eaten within hours of coming out of the oven. It has been so fun to share your bread.
    My next recipe is your cinnamon rolls. I need twice the recipe for my family. I’m going to try to double the recipe to save time. We all are looking forward to this new treat.

    • JoshLovesIt
      August 20, 2014

      I’m glad you liked the bread, and hope the cinnamon rolls work out!

  74. debbie
    September 11, 2014

    Hi josh, I see your using all purpose flour, in England that is plain flour or should I use strong white bread flour, they look amazing thanks for sharing x

    • JoshLovesIt
      September 11, 2014

      Hi Debbie, I’m sure plain flour will work. But you could try bread flour and let me know how it goes!

  75. Lena
    September 12, 2014

    I went to the site and still don’t see where the ingredients are for your 7 minute world’s best french bread recipe.

    • JoshLovesIt
      December 31, 2014

      Lena, did you click on the PDF for the recipe?

  76. Billie
    September 15, 2014

    For some reason, yeast and bread making has always intimidated me. But, after I watched your video, I thought I’d give it a try. The bread turned out very good. I was pleasantly surprised and so pleased that I have found a bread recipe I can manage. I’ve already made this bread twice and am getting ready to make it a third time.
    Thank you very much for providing the video!

    • JoshLovesIt
      December 31, 2014

      I’m so glad the bread worked out for you Billie!

  77. Ava
    October 4, 2014

    Hi Josh….Best bread ever!! thank you for sharing!!

    • JoshLovesIt
      December 31, 2014

      You’re welcome Ava!

  78. Urbano
    December 14, 2014

    I made this bread this afternoon. Turned out AMAZINNNNNNGGGGGGGG! I watched your U2B video and it was very simple. Man I let that bread rise for 4 hrs. My break shape was kinda oblong shape. But hey, still great!!! I need to get a bread pan. Thank you!

    • JoshLovesIt
      December 31, 2014

      I’m glad the bread worked out Urbano!

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

Back to top
mobile desktop